Battery chargers
by Chris Woodford. Last updated: February 11, 2023.
Power to go—aren't batteries brilliant? The trouble is, they store only a fixed amount of electric charge before running flat, usually at the most inconvenient of times. If you use rechargeable batteries, that's less of a problem: click your batteries in the charger, plug in, and in a few hours they're as good as new and ready to use again. A typical rechargeable battery can be charged up hundreds of times, may last you anything from three or four years to a decade or more, and will probably save you hundreds of dollars in buying disposables (so it's brilliant for the environment too). But exactly how well your batteries perform depends on how you use them and how carefully you charge them. That's why a decent battery charger is as important as the batteries you put into it. What is a battery charger and how does it work? Let's take a closer look!
Photo: Solar-powered battery chargers, like this one made by BEAM, are sure to become increasingly common as more of us switch to electric cars. The overhead canopy contains a 4.3kW, photovoltaic, sun-tracking solar panel and feeds onboard batteries so it even works at night. It can charge up to six electric vehicles at a time. Photo by Erin Rohn courtesy of US Marine Corps and DVIDS.
Sponsored links
Contents
What are batteries and how do they work?
If you've read our main article on batteries, you'll know all about these portable power plants. An example of what scientists refer to as electrochemistry, they use the power of chemistry to release stored electricity very gradually.
What happens inside a typical battery—like the one in a flashlight? When you click the power switch, you're giving the green light to chemical reactions inside the battery. As the current starts flowing, the cells (power-generating compartments) inside the battery begin to transform themselves in startling but entirely invisible ways. The chemicals from which their components are made begin to rearrange themselves. Inside each cell, chemical reactions take place involving the two electrical terminals (or electrodes) and a chemical known as the electrolyte that separate them. These chemical reactions cause electrons (the tiny particles inside atoms that carry electricity) to pump around the circuit the battery is connected to, providing power to the flashlight. But the cells inside a battery contain only limited supplies of chemicals so the reactions cannot continue indefinitely. Once the chemicals are depleted, the reactions stop, the electrons cease flowing through the outer circuit, the battery is effectively flat—and your lamp goes out.
Photo: Ordinary batteries (like this everyday zinc-carbon battery) are only designed to be used once—so don't attempt to recharge them. If you don't like zinc carbon batteries, don't start trying to recharge them: buy rechargeable ones to begin with.
That's the bad news. The good news is that if you're using a rechargeable battery, you can make the chemical reactions run in reverse using a battery charger. Charging up a battery is the exact opposite of discharging it: where discharging gives out energy, charging takes energy in and stores it by resetting the battery chemicals to how they were originally. In theory, you can charge and discharge a rechargeable battery any number of times; in practice, even rechargeable batteries degrade over time and there eventually comes a point where they're no longer willing to store charge. At that point, you have to recycle them or throw them away.
How battery chargers work
All battery chargers have one thing in common: they work by feeding a DC electric current through batteries for a period of time in the hope that the cells inside will hold on to some of the energy passing through them. That's roughly where the similarity between chargers begins and ends!
Charging methods
There are, broadly speaking, two different ways to charge a battery: quickly or slowly. Fast charging essentially means using a higher charging current for a shorter time, whereas slow charging uses a lower current for longer. That doesn't mean the charging process is just a simple matter of passing a steady current through the battery until it's charged. There are several common methods of charging (plus a few more we won't go into here). [1]
Photo: Battery chargers look simple, but they're surprisingly complex inside. Different types of rechargeable batteries need charging in different ways, for different times, sometimes using several different methods in turn, which make up what's called the charging algorithm. A charger like this is constantly sensing what the batteries inside it are doing and adjusting the charging process accordingly.
Pulse charging involves sending intermittent pulses of high current through the battery, with rest periods in between to allow the battery chemicals to absorb the charge. In crude terms, the pulses are a little bit like the thumping charges to the chest you see an emergency responder giving to someone who's suffered a cardiac arrest, except that they continue until the battery's voltage climbs toward its rated, peak value and the battery is fully charged. (Pulse charging can also be useful for reviving older, degraded batteries, such as lead-acid or nickel-cadmium, in which crystals have grown and impeded the batteries' ability to keep on working; the pulses of electricity break the crystals down so the battery works normally again.)
In taper-current charging, the charger starts off using a high, constant current, which progressively lowers to a trickle as the battery fills with charge and reaches its peak voltage. Inexpensive chargers often work this way. [8]
Two alternative ways of charging are constant current (CC) and constant voltage (CV). As their names suggest, constant current applies a steady current (usually the battery's peak current), while constant voltage applies a steady voltage (usually the battery's peak voltage), and the two are often used together, one after another, in constant current constant voltage (CCCV) chargers. Typically, they start off applying a constant current until the battery voltage passes a certain threshold; then they apply a constant voltage until the current passes another threshold. Another variation is two-step constant-current charging that begins with a fast high-current charge and switches to a slower, lower-current charge part way through the process. [9]
Photo: This "fast-charge" battery charger is designed to charge four cylindrical nickel-cadmium (nicad) batteries in five hours or one square-shaped RX22 battery in 16 hours. I think it's an example of a constant-current or maybe taper-current charger, though I've not tested it to find out. It's easy to use, and just as easy to misuse: there's nothing to tell you when charging is complete. With a battery charger like this, charging batteries is complete guesswork.
The final method is called trickle charging, and is similar to constant current charging but uses a much smaller current (perhaps 5–10 percent) for much longer. Some appliances (like cordless phones and electric toothbrushes) are designed to sit on trickle chargers indefinitely.
However you charge, it's worth remembering that, in a very crude sense, batteries are a bit like suitcases: the more you pack in, the harder it is to pack in any more—and the longer it takes. That's easy to understand if you remember that charging a battery essentially involves reversing the chemical reactions that take place when it discharges and supplies useful current. In a laptop battery, for example, charging and discharging involve shunting lithium ions (atoms missing electrons) back and forth, from one electrode (where there are many of them) to another electrode (where there are few). Since the ions all carry a positive charge, it's easier to move them to the "empty" electrode at the start. As they start to build up there, it gets harder to pack more of them in, making the later stages of charging harder work than the earlier ones.
Graph: Batteries get harder to charge in the later stages. It can take as long to charge the last 25 percent of a battery (red area) as the first 75 percent (orange area). [2] It's worth remembering this if you have limited time to charge a battery and worry that it'll take too long: you might be able to charge it halfway in much less time than you think. If the battery in this example takes an hour to charge, you can see that it would reach 50 percent charge (dotted lines) in just 6.5 minutes.
Charging algorithms
Different charging methods are suited to different types of batteries. Simple pulse charging works well for nickel cadmium and nickel metal-hydride batteries, which are also widely charged by the constant current (CC) method, but pulse charging is quite crude and unsuitable for lithium-ion batteries, which are generally charged by CCCV instead.
Better chargers work more intelligently, combining different types of charging in sequence according to how the battery performs as it's being charged. So, for example, a battery may be slowly pre-charged (by trickle charging) for a short time to test how well it's accepting charge, then fast-charged fully by CC and CV, which may be alternated multiple times. [3] The combination of charging methods used by a particular charger is known as its charging algorithm.
Graph: A simple charging algorithm might involve three stages: brief trickle charging to test the battery followed by periods of fast constant-current and constant-voltage charging. [7]
Charging time
The ideal charging time varies for all sorts of reasons (how much charge the battery held to begin with, how hot it is, how old it is, whether one cell is performing better than others, and so on). How does a charger know when to stop? Different methods are used for different types of batteries, and for slow charge or fast charge. The best chargers work intelligently, using microchip-based electronic circuits to sense how much charge is stored in the batteries, figuring out from such things as changes in the battery voltage (technically called delta V or ΔV) and cell temperature (delta T or ΔT) when the charging is likely to be "done," and then switching off the current or changing to a low trickle charge at the appropriate time.
There's usually a primary method of figuring out that the charge is complete (such as measuring the voltage) and one or more backup methods (temperature changes or a preset timer). [4] NiCd chargers, for example, often use a primary method called −ΔV (also written negative delta V or NDV, which refers to the slight voltage drop that a NiCd battery shows just after it's fully charged), with a backup timer or temperature-change detector. NiMH chargers are more likely to rely on temperature changes as their primary method with a backup timer cut-off circuit. In theory, it's impossible to overcharge or undercharge with an intelligent charger.
Photo: The Innovations Battery Manager, popular in the 1990s, was sold as an intelligent battery charger capable of recharging even ordinary zinc-carbon and alkaline batteries. Right: A digital display showed the voltage of each battery as it charged (in this case, 1.39 volts). After charging, a little bar graph appeared showing how good a condition the battery was in (how many more times you could charge it). Many thousands of these chargers were sold, but there were differing opinions on how well they worked.
If you're charging batteries, you probably think fast charge is automatically better—you want to use your laptop or phone as soon as you can. But it comes with major drawbacks. The chemicals in batteries take time to absorb charge and faster charging can shorten the life of a battery (a big problem for things like expensive electric car batteries), or risk safety problems such as overheating and fires. [5]
Multiple batteries
Most chargers are designed to charge two, three, or four batteries at the same time, which adds a few extra complications. If you simply connect them in series and try to charge them, how do you know which batteries are in a good condition and charging well and which ones are poorer and accepting less charge? One battery is almost certain to reach full charge before the others, so it's almost inevitable that some will be overcharged (and potentially damaged) while others remain undercharged. Decent battery chargers get around this with circuits that monitor each battery individually, switching off or reducing its charging current to a trickle, independently, when it's fully charged. [6]
AC and DC
Batteries are direct current (DC) devices: current flows in one way (during charging) and out the other (during discharging). But most of us live in homes with alternating current (AC) supplies, so plug-in battery chargers have to convert AC electricity to DC before they can charge the batteries you want to put into them. Exactly how they do this affects the quality of the DC charging current and how cleanly and effectively they charge. Typically, AC-powered chargers use some combination of step-down transformers (to convert high voltages, typically 110–240 volts, to lower ones more like 1.5–20 volts); rectifiers (diode-type circuits) and thyristors (silicon controlled rectifiers), to convert AC to DC; and integrated circuits to filter and smooth their output.
Sponsored links
Charging different kinds of rechargeable batteries
To complicate matters, different types of rechargeable batteries respond best to different types of charging, so a charger suitable for one type of battery may not work well with another.
Nickel-based batteries
Photos: An electric toothbrush typically contains either nicad or NiMH batteries and slowly or trickle charges on a stand, which is actually an induction charger.
Nickel cadmium (also called "nicad" or NiCd), the oldest and perhaps still best known types of everyday rechargeable batteries, respond best either to fairly rapid charging (providing it doesn't make them hot) or slow trickle charging. [10]
Nickel metal hydride (NiMH) batteries use newer technology and look exactly the same as nicads, but they're generally more expensive because they can store more charge (shown on the battery packaging as a higher rating in mAH or milliampere-hours). NiMH batteries can be fast charged (on high current for several hours, at the risk of overheating), slow charged (for about 12–16 hours using a lower current), or briefly trickle charged (with a much lower current than nicad), but they should really be charged only with an NiMH charger: a rapid nicad charger may overcharge NiMH batteries.
Expert opinions seem to differ on whether nickel batteries experience what's widely known as the memory effect. This is the well-reported phenomenon where failure to discharge a nickel-based battery before charging (when you're "topping up" a partly discharged battery with a quick recharge) reputedly causes permanent chemical changes that reduce how much charge the battery will accept in future. Some people swear the memory effort is real; others are equally insistent that it's a myth. The real explanation for an apparent memory effect is voltage depression, where a battery that hasn't been fully discharged before charging temporarily "thinks" it has a lower voltage and charge-storing capacity than it should have. Battery experts insist you can cure this problem by charging and discharging a battery fully a few times more.
It's generally agreed that nickel-based batteries need to be "primed" (charged fully before they're used for the first time), so be sure to follow exactly what the manufacturers say when you take your new batteries out of the packet.